Visits to two art districts in Shanhai, and a long talk with an American-born photo gallery owner brought up the question of originality again. This is a recurring theme, both in photography and in China. Over dinner last night a software engineer lamented that his programmers ask for too much direction. They want to implement, not design.
Similarly, the gallery owner spoke of work that is authentically creative, rather than derivative of others work. We pointed to Photoshopped collage work of which there is a wide variety here–but quite a bit of it looks the same. Part of the argument came down to: who did it first. And how is the technique being pushed? Heading through Moganshan, anime girls and dirty Chairman Maos greeted us left and right. Do the questions hold here? Or if an artist finds pleasure and a market in creating something that is a bit of a trope, does it matter? Many photographers continue to make landscapes that are pretty, but hardly original. Conceptually there is certainly nothing new.
The same with hot pot or Uighur food. Not much original. In tonight’s case, well-cooked lamb, the laoban singing kareoke while his daughter dances in an ethnic costume, pullinh a mix of Chinese and foreign customers onto the dance floor with the waiters, and black Xinjiang beer added up to a pleasant dinner out. It just doesn’t matter that it was hardly original–the same thing happens in Greek Town in Chicago. The difference between craft and art? Perhaps just the price tag.
Well, there have been little ones, and this one didn’t result in anything bad happening or having to choke down anything unexpected for lunch, but it’s worth relaying anyway.
After the overnight train from Beijing we queued up for a taxi to the hotel. With notebook in hand, I told the driver that we’re headed to Motel 168–he finished the sentence for me, which is always a good sign. So I said the address (there’s lots of Motel 168s, and ours has a 268 next door–I’m not sure if it’s better or worse). 1119 Yan’an Road. “Er, Er, Er, Jiu.” You see where this is going.
A bit down the highway we pass a 168. ‘That one’s not yours.’ We get off the highway and ‘Damn, I went too far.’ He turned off the meter, which I thought was a nice touch, and hooked a u-turn. We went back a few blocks and there was a bit of muttering under his breath. After a bit of confusion, he pulls to the side and jumps out and talks to a security guard. I pull out the Lonely Planet and when he gets back I say ‘I have a map.’ To which he replies (I’m guessing) ‘why didn’t you tell me you had a map.’ And I point to the intersection. Jiangsu Road and Yan’an Road intersection. He looks at me like I’m an idiot. ‘你说了二二二九。 那个不是什么什么什么!’ He’s annoyed. I’m confused. I hold my ground and start toning hard. There’s a bit of back and forth. He obviously knows exactly what I’m saying, but I’m only catching a bit of him. “You said…you said….” I open my notebook and point to the address: “看。 一一一….”
I had told him 2229 Yan’an Road. The address is 1119. Oddly, a properly formed and pronounced “Fuck. I’m so embarrassed” (‘zao. 不好意思’) falls immediately out of my mouth. He laughed at that and pulled back on the road. All the way he chuckled ‘一一一…. 二二二…’ And continued to refuse to turn the meter back on.
While tipping is not a custom in China, I insisted. It is the guy’s gas after all.
Obviously, if this is the worst thing that happens this week, we’ll be fine.
A very pleasant space in which I spent alot of time on my last trip to Beijing was the DiSanJi Bookstore–an 8 story complex that included 4 floors (at least) with the others devoted to other small retailers. There were also several upscale restaurants, a food court in the basement, and a Western-style coffeeshop with free wi-fi. It was a post-lunch study space for me.
It was sparkly and brand new when I was here in 2007, and most of the spaces were rented. It’s not aging well: there’s a ton of vacancies; the kiosks are all gone; no more coffeeshop; and the top floor of the bookstore is closed. Bad economy you might say, but I’m not sure if that explains the lack of building maintenance. This building had public toilets that supplied paper and were rather sparkly. Now, the paper holders have become places for people to rest their cigarettes, the towel dispensers are gone, and there’s more than a handful of out-of-order stalls. The food-court shows wear-and-tear as well. At the bottom of the escalator, dust-bunnies hang from the ceiling (which I imagine in 2007 would have been wiped down twice daily. With a dirty rag maybe, but wiped nonetheless). Beyond cleanliness, the frosted glass floor tiles were obviously not set correctly, as water and grime have worked themselves between the layers of glass.
What’s going on here? I can understand shrinking the store down. And I can understand some pieces of construction starting to decay because of design or execution flaws. But the cleanliness combined with the other factors confuses me a bit. I would have guessed that the overly-zealous cleaning staff would have been the last to be let go.
The history of the area was given to me only by word-of-mouth. Apparently the district used to be filled with booksellers. Once economic changes took hold, the booksellers were consolidated into 3 big retail stores, and a building of stalls (which we didn’t have time for yesterday). Several office towers were built, and the area rebranded as part of Haidian’s hi-tech business park. The condition of the bookstore makes me wonder how much office space has become available as tech firms have gone bust? The surrounding area continues to develop, with the Sinosteel tower dominating the scene and other buildings continuing to go up. If time permitted, I would have liked to have gone back through some of the other buildings to see how time is treating them. Darn this fast trip.
Many changes have greeted me upon my return to Beijing, but I think it’s essence is unchanged. One surprise is how well I have been able to navigate and communicate–although we’ve had all bi-lingual menus so far. Another is that we visited a large office building this morning and the signpost in front had several corporate logos scraped off of it. So while there are signs in the landscape that the recession has hit here, the streets are just as vibrant, the physical labor is just as visible, and the prices appear to be about the same.
We chose well for a hotel here and are comfortable in a courtyard house close to the center of the city. Tonight we reunite with friends from BeiDa and we discuss the current state of libraries and my rapidly advancing age. I add a decade today, and being in China is a pretty good substitution for a cake.
I guess there’s three inspirations to start this up again.
- The thesis is finished and approved. The ending was drawn out due to my part-time status and a desire to stick to the academic year. This really was for the best, and allowed a full quarter at the end (when I was finishing my last distribution credits) to polish the manuscript for the graduate school.
- I’m heading back ‘into the field’ next week for a quick trip back to 中国。 ‘Into the field’ should probably be taken lightly, but I am looking forward to see how much 2 years can change the landscape.
- Constant news this week that recession is easing up in Asia. While there was definitely a lot of news of an unemployment spike in China, the US’s own economic woes, combined with the shrill tone of health-care reform and those darn Uighurs drowned out alot of substantive information, unless you went digging.
Three news items perhaps sum up the current state of affairs. First is the news about the economy. The shorter news reports credited government spending and a lack of hi-risk, complicated financial products for the quick recovery. Government spending is, of course, part of it. Train lines, college campuses, and other public-sector project in China are almost certainly still underway. But the deeper story from a couple years ago must also be true: that the market planners were setting their sites on developing internal consumers. The rationale in 2007 was not that income from exported manufactured good was about to dry up, but that the export market was just about saturated with $40 DVD players. It was time to re-tool to outfit the growing Chinese consumer classes. So it will be interesting to see if the pace of change in the cities that I visited on my last trip has continued unabated.
Secondly, those darn Uighurs. It struck me last night that one of the meals I’m most looking forward to is Iughur food in Beijing. Would this be a bit like craving soul food during the race riots of the 1960s? What’s the atmosphere like at the giant outdoor dining rooms in Beijing?
Finally there are the typhoons. Mudslides in Zhejiang Province and Taiwan show that no matter how deep economic changes go, nature and climate can step in and wipe out gains in human development with a good hard rain. Jinan had flooded just a few days before my trip there in 2007, and alot of people were obviously occupied with cleaning up. The Yellow and Yangtze Rivers have flooded annually for thousands of years. While huge loss of life is now rare, none of the imperial and PRC efforts to engineer the rivers have changed the fact that if you dump a foot of rain on a city in a day, there’s going to be flooding. Whether it’s Chicago or Beijing–it gets messy.
And so we will go this week to meet up with old friends and new, take a peak at Beijing, Shanghai, Shenzhen, and Hong Kong, and lay a few plans for a more extended trip in 2010-11. And now that I am ‘officially’ not a student, perhaps this blog will offer more frequent commentary on the information landscape of China.